Homepage intro

Home heating and cooling, explained plainly.

Straight answers from an HVAC engineer: why your system does what it does, and what actually lowers the bill.

FurnaceHeat pumpBoilerWater heaterThermostatHeating bills

Latest posts

Water Heater Warm to the Touch? That Heat Is on Your Bill

The touch test: a bare older tank feels warm because heat is leaving it all day; a wrapped one loses far less.


Put your hand flat on the side of your water heater. If the steel feels warm, you are paying to heat the basement, one quiet degree at a time. On an older electric tank that warmth can add up to about $40 a year in heat you never use, and a $20 to $30 insulating blanket gets most of it back in a Saturday morning. Newer tanks and gas tanks are a different story, and I will get to them.

Why a warm tank is an expensive tank

A storage water heater keeps 50 gallons (189 L) of water at about 120 degrees F (49 degrees C) around the clock, whether anyone showers or not. The basement around it might sit at 60 degrees F (16 degrees C). Heat flows from warm to cold, so the tank leaks heat through its walls all night and the element or burner keeps switching on to replace it. Engineers call this standby loss.

Think of a mug of coffee. A thin mug gets hot on the outside and the coffee cools fast. An insulated travel mug stays cool to the touch and keeps the coffee hot for hours.

Insulation is the whole story. Tanks built before 2015 often have only an inch or so of foam inside the steel shell, and those are the ones that feel warm. In April 2015 a tougher US efficiency rule took effect and manufacturers added roughly another inch of foam. That is why a new tank is two inches wider than the old one, and why it feels like room temperature. A blanket on one of those gains very little.

I once checked two houses on the same street in one afternoon. The first had a twenty-year-old electric tank in a cool basement, and it felt like a warm mug. The second had a tank only a few years old, and it felt like the wall beside it. Same water temperature inside. The only difference was the foam.

Gas tanks are different again. Most of their standby heat escapes up the flue pipe that runs through the middle of the tank, where no blanket can reach. A blanket helps a little on the sides, but it must stay clear of the burner door, the draft hood and the controls, so the gain is smaller and the risk is real.

The touch test, then the fix

  1. Feel the tank. Warm on an electric tank means wrap it. Room temperature means leave it alone and spend the money on pipe insulation instead.
  2. Buy a water heater blanket rated R-8 or better. Turn off the breaker, wrap the sides, and cut neat openings for the two thermostat access panels, the drain and the pressure relief valve. Never cover a warning label. With a blanket on, keep the thermostat at or below 130 degrees F (54 degrees C).
  3. On a gas tank, wrap only the sides. The top, the bottom, the burner access door, the controls and the relief valve stay open to the air. If the owner's manual says no blanket, believe it.
  4. Slip foam sleeves over the first 3 feet (1 m) of both the hot and the cold pipe leaving the tank. Hot water reaches the tap a couple of degrees warmer, which lets you turn the dial down a notch. Keep any insulation at least 6 inches (15 cm) from a gas flue.

On one service call the homeowner had wrapped a gas tank beautifully, right over the top, with the blanket tucked around the draft hood. I took that part off before I did anything else. The top of a gas tank is where the exhaust leaves the appliance, and it stays bare.

For European readers the picture splits in two. A combi boiler heats water on demand and has no tank, so there is nothing to wrap. If you have a hot water cylinder in an airing cupboard (common in British and Irish homes, and standard with an air-to-water heat pump), the same touch test applies: a bare copper cylinder wants a jacket at least 80 mm (3 in) thick, while a modern foam-clad cylinder is already dressed for the job.

When the blanket is not the answer

If the tank is warm to the touch and also past fifteen years old, the blanket is a stopgap. Price the replacement now, before it fails on a holiday weekend, and ask the installer about a heat pump water heater while you are at it. Do not wrap a heat pump water heater; it needs air moving around it. Anything that touches the gas line, the burner or the vent is a licensed job, not a weekend one.

My own rule: a tank less than ten years old gets pipe sleeves from me, not a blanket. The foam inside is already doing the job, and on a gas unit a blanket mostly gets in the way of the next service visit.

Go deeper: the standby loss arithmetic

Standby loss through the shell is plain conduction: Q = A × ΔT ÷ R. Take an older 50-gallon electric tank with about 30 sq ft (2.8 m2) of shell and 1 to 1.5 in of foam (about R-8) in a room 60 degrees F (33 degrees C) colder than the water. Q = 30 × 60 ÷ 8 = 225 BTU/h, which is 1.6 kWh a day and about 580 kWh a year. At the 18 cents per kWh the EIA projects as the 2026 US residential average, that is about $104 a year for water nobody drew.

An R-8 blanket over about 25 sq ft of sides and top doubles the resistance where it sits: 25 × 60 ÷ 8 falls to 25 × 60 ÷ 16, saving about 94 BTU/h, 0.66 kWh a day, 240 kWh a year, roughly $43. That is 42% of the standby loss, inside the 25 to 45% range the US Department of Energy quotes, and the blanket repays itself within a year.

Against actual use it looks smaller, which is why the DOE frames it as 7 to 16% of water heating cost. A household drawing 50 gallons a day, heated 60 degrees F, needs 50 × 8.34 × 60 = about 25,000 BTU (7.3 kWh) a day, so standby is 18% of water heating energy and the blanket saves about 7%. A newer R-16 tank halves everything and stretches the payback to about two years.

Two caveats. A tank inside the heated envelope gives its winter losses to the house, and in summer the air conditioner must remove that heat. On a gas tank the central flue is a steel tube bathed in tank water, and natural draft keeps pulling room air up it with the burner off, so most of its standby loss takes a path no blanket touches. Pipe sleeves are the small line item: the DOE puts them at 2 to 4 degrees F (1 to 2 degrees C) warmer water at the tap and 3 to 4% off water heating energy.

Sources

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Did You Overpay for Your AC? A Lawsuit Says Maybe

Image
Price change since January 2020 as stated in the class-action complaint: HVAC equipment, kitchen appliances, and prices in general. Seven companies that make most of the air conditioners, furnaces and heat pumps sold in the United States are being sued for fixing prices. On October 9 they asked a federal judge in Michigan to throw the case out. Here is the short version. Nothing in the case changes what you should do this fall, and the biggest savings on a new system still come from the quotes you collect, not from a courtroom. What the lawsuit says, and what the makers say back The suits were filed this spring by homeowners and by contractors. They name Carrier, Trane, Lennox, Daikin, Rheem, Bosch and AAON, which between them sell most of the heating and cooling equipment in the country. The claim is simple: since 2020 these companies raised prices in step with each other, by more than their costs went up, and signaled their plans to one another through public announcements an...
Read more

A $3 Sheet of Plastic Can Halve a Window's Heat Loss

Image
Bare glass versus the same window with a taped film: about half the heat loss. Hold your hand near a bare window on a cold night and you can feel the heat leaving the room. The fix is cheaper than almost anything else in home energy: a clear plastic film kit, taped to the window frame and shrunk tight with a hair dryer. On a single-pane window it cuts the heat flowing out through the glass by about half. On a double-pane window, by about a third. Glass is not the insulator. The air is. This is the part that surprises people. A pane of glass barely slows heat at all. Almost all of a bare window's insulating value comes from the thin layer of still air that clings to each side of the glass. Those two air layers do the work. The glass just holds them apart. A film kit adds a second pocket of trapped air, about an inch (2.5 cm) deep, between the film and the glass. That pocket resists heat about as well as the two air layers combined. So the window ends up with roughly double the...
Read more